The following are a list of past Sheriffs of Elkhart County and the year they took office.
1830 Eli Penwell
1832 James Beck
1836 Joseph DeFreese
1840 Albert Banter
1844 Elbersen Brown
1848 Peter Roler
1850 David Mathy
1852 C.W. Seely
1856 G.L. Kiblings
1860 A.C. Manning
1862 William Vesey
1864 John Violett
1866 Edward Kerstetter
1870 John Egbert
1874 Samuel Miller
1878 Christopher Gillette
1882 Charles Thompson
1886 Robert Chatheu
1890 Elliott Crull
1894 Orlando Purinton
1896 Hiram Kidder
1898 William Elliott
1902 Elmer Manning
1906 John Ziesel
1910 Frank Leader
1912 Scott Thomas
1916 Charles Sanford
1920 Arthur Fonda
1924 Thomas Long
1928 Glenn Banks
1930 Merl Forry
1934 Edward Bourke
1938 Ralph Logan
1942 Bernard Buckley
1946 Luther Yoder
1950 Vernon Cripe
1958 Woody Caton
1966 LeRoy Miller
1970 Edward Robinson
1975 Dick Bowman
1986 Randall Yohn
1995 Thomas Snider
2003 Michael Books
2011 Bradley Rogers
2019 Jeffrey Siegel